The Takeout Fry

(page 2 of 3)

Photo by Nicole PeasleeCrandall's Catering

6401 University Ave., Middleton
231-2000, crandallscatering.com

The only real ambience Crandall’s offers visitors is also the most revealing. That’d be the long line of cars clogging the drive-through loop at the catering company’s modest University Avenue location.

Nearly seventy years after the physical restaurant first opened on the Square—back then, they advertised steak, not fish, as their primary specialty—Crandall’s is still serving the same fish fry recipe that’s worth waiting in the que to score. The fish, of course, forms the backbone of the experience—fried Atlantic cod, haddock and perch, with baked options, too—but the potato options are what bring it to another level. If you’re smart, you’ll opt for the roasted reds, covered in a cheese sauce that makes ’em the perfect complement.

Ivan Pimentel, who’s owned Crandall’s since 1994, now offers the fry every weeknight in addition to his business’s catering services. On typical Fridays, his staff will box up an average of three hundred orders, a number that leaps as high as 450 during Lent. Given the weekly volume, Pimentel has learned to plan for any eventuality. Three years ago, he ran out of cod and perch and had to switch to a different fish. Customers noticed—and revolted. “I learned not to run out,” he deadpans. “I invested in a walk-in freezer.” 

Picasso's >>

Bookmark and Share Email this page Email Print this page Print

Travel

Biking Beautiful Viroqua

Biking Beautiful Viroqua

Discover challenging bike rides and gorgeous southwest Wisconsin scenery

Make These 7 Pit Stops on a Summer Road Trip to Yellowstone

Make These 7 Pit Stops on a Summer Road Trip to Yellowstone

A guide to the best kitsch, culture and nature on the journey from Madison to Yellowstone National Park

Health Features

Pet Projects

Pet Projects

Healthy living isn’t limited to humans—your pet needs special care, too

Top Docs 2014

Top Docs 2014

Our biennial guide reveals the Madison area’s best physicians—as chosen by their peers in the local medical community

Summer Skin Health

Summer Skin Health

Want to look and feel your best this summer? Protect yourself and take control!